Produce less. Distribute it fairly. Create a greener world for all.

The Spectre of Capital, Subaltern Studies and the Caste–Class Dialectic

The relationship between capitalism, caste and class remains central to understanding inequality and social oppression in India. Examining Vivek Chibber’s materialist critique of Subaltern Studies alongside the responses of postcolonial scholars, Pon Chandran explores the tensions between universal theories of capital and the specific historical structures of Indian society. The article brings this debate into…

Written by

Pon Chandran

–

in

–

Originally Published in

Countercurrents

The relationship between capitalism, caste and social hierarchy remains one of the most consequential questions in understanding modern Indian society. It also raises a larger theoretical problem: can the historical experience of Western capitalism provide a universal framework for understanding societies in the Global South, or must the analysis of these societies begin with their distinctive cultural, political and social formations?

This question lies at the heart of the debate between Marxist political economy and postcolonial theory, particularly the intellectual confrontation between Vivek Chibber and the Subaltern Studies collective. The debate extends beyond competing interpretations of history. It concerns the nature of power, the sources of oppression, the possibilities of collective resistance and the conditions necessary for human emancipation.

The discussion becomes especially significant when considered alongside Dr. B.R. Ambedkar’s analysis of caste. His understanding of social hierarchy presents a fundamental challenge to conventional class-centred interpretations of exploitation and raises important questions about the relationship between economic transformation and social emancipation.

The challenge to postcolonial exceptionalism

In his 2013 book, Postcolonial Theory and the Specter of Capital, sociologist Vivek Chibber develops a materialist critique of Postcolonial Theory, concentrating particularly on the intellectual contributions of the Subaltern Studies collective, including Ranajit Guha, Dipesh Chakrabarty and Partha Chatterjee.

A central concern of Subaltern Studies was the inadequacy of conventional historical accounts that placed political elites and dominant social groups at the centre of historical transformation. Its scholars sought to recover the agency of subordinate populations and examine the distinctive ways in which power operated in colonial and postcolonial societies.

One influential argument associated with Ranajit Guha concerned the historical limitations of the Indian bourgeoisie. European bourgeois revolutions, in this interpretation, had established a form of political dominance supported by hegemony, whereas the Indian bourgeoisie had failed to achieve a comparable transformation. Colonial and postcolonial ruling classes relied more extensively on coercion and domination than on securing broader social consent.

Chibber challenges the historical assumptions underlying this distinction. He argues that the European bourgeoisie did not establish democratic rights and universal political freedoms simply through its own progressive character. These achievements were substantially the outcome of struggles waged by workers and other subordinate groups against established economic and political power.

Consequently, the failure of the Indian bourgeoisie to establish a fully democratic social order cannot be treated as an exceptional postcolonial failure. The European experience itself demonstrates that capitalist classes have historically resisted democratic demands whenever these threatened their economic interests.

For Chibber, the behaviour of capital is governed primarily by the requirements of accumulation and the preservation of economic power, rather than by any inherent commitment to democracy or universal rights.

This argument challenges the tendency to construct a sharp historical division between Western and non-Western societies. Capitalism may develop through different political and cultural arrangements, but its fundamental economic imperatives remain recognisable across geographical boundaries.

The universality of capital and the limits of cultural explanations

Another major dimension of Chibber’s critique concerns the relationship between universal human needs and culturally specific forms of social organisation.

Some postcolonial interpretations emphasise that societies outside Europe cannot be adequately understood through categories derived from European intellectual and historical experience. Their social relations, political identities and forms of resistance are shaped by particular cultural traditions, religious beliefs, community structures and historical experiences.

Chibber challenges the extent to which such distinctions can be used to separate the experience of the Global South from the fundamental dynamics of capitalism.

He maintains that people subjected to exploitation and oppression seek to defend their livelihoods, material security and bodily integrity. These interests are not exclusive to any particular civilisation or cultural tradition. Workers and subordinate populations resist conditions that threaten their ability to sustain themselves, irrespective of the cultural language through which their resistance is expressed.

Similarly, capitalist production imposes market discipline across societies. The need to secure employment, income and access to resources subjects individuals and communities to economic pressures that cannot be explained exclusively through cultural differences.

This does not mean that capitalism produces identical societies everywhere. Chibber makes an important distinction between the universal economic imperatives of capital and the cultural forms through which those imperatives operate.

Capital requires accumulation, profit extraction and the discipline of labour. It does not necessarily require societies to adopt Western cultural values, secularism or liberal democratic institutions.

Capitalism can operate through inherited social hierarchies and established cultural arrangements. Caste, patriarchy and other forms of social inequality can be accommodated within capitalist production when they help maintain existing relations of exploitation.

This distinction is central to Chibber’s engagement with Dipesh Chakrabarty’s Provincializing Europe. The universal operation of capital does not imply that every society must follow an identical historical path or reproduce European cultural and political institutions.

The economic logic of capitalism can coexist with considerable cultural and institutional diversity.

The Subaltern response: History, culture and political agency

The arguments advanced by Chibber have generated substantial responses from postcolonial and Subaltern Studies scholars. These responses, brought together in debates including those collected in Rosie Warren’s edited volume The Debate on Postcolonial Theory and the Specter of Capital, question the adequacy of a materialist framework when applied to the complex social realities of the Global South.

One major criticism concerns the possibility that Chibber reduces diverse historical experiences to abstract categories derived from European Marxist thought.

Resistance does not always emerge in the form of organised economic struggles or through an explicitly class-conscious understanding of exploitation. Religious beliefs, caste identities, community relationships and local understandings of justice can shape how subordinate populations interpret their conditions and organise collective action.

For critics of Chibber, these dimensions cannot be treated merely as cultural expressions of an underlying material interest. They are also important sites through which power is exercised, identities are constructed and resistance acquires political meaning.

Partha Chatterjee and Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak have challenged aspects of Chibber’s interpretation of Subaltern Studies. Their concern is that the critique does not sufficiently recognise the original intellectual purpose of the collective.

Subaltern Studies was not necessarily intended to deny the existence or significance of global capitalism. Rather, it sought to examine how power operated through particular historical institutions, political languages and social relationships that conventional Marxist historiography frequently neglected.

The question of subaltern agency was particularly important. Traditional historical narratives often classified popular movements outside established forms of class politics as pre-political or insufficiently developed. Subaltern historians sought to challenge this assumption by examining the independent political consciousness and historical initiatives of subordinate populations.

Another point of disagreement concerns the relationship between economic structures and cultural autonomy. If capital’s economic imperatives are treated as universally decisive, there is a danger that cultural institutions and social identities will be reduced to secondary expressions of economic relations.

The critics argue that such an approach may overlook the independent capacity of caste, religion and community structures to organise social power.

The emergence of Subaltern Studies itself was connected to the historical limitations of sections of the traditional Left in South Asia. Left political organisations frequently concentrated on class relations while giving insufficient attention to caste oppression, religious communalism and the continuing influence of colonial administrative structures.

The disagreement, therefore, is not simply between materialism and cultural analysis. It concerns how these dimensions interact and how a comprehensive account of historical transformation can incorporate both.

Indian historiography and the class-caste relationship

The debate between Chibber and Subaltern Studies has important implications for the writing of Indian history.

Classical Marxist historiography often interpreted caste as a remnant of pre-capitalist or feudal social relations. Industrialisation and the expansion of capitalist production were expected to weaken inherited hierarchies by transforming economic relationships and creating a more unified working class.

Subaltern Studies questioned this historical expectation. It drew attention to the persistence of caste and community-based power in modern political and economic institutions. Social identities continued to shape access to resources, political representation and opportunities for collective organisation.

Chibber’s intervention restores the centrality of material relations to this discussion. Capitalism does not necessarily dismantle inherited hierarchies. It can utilise them to organise labour, suppress wages and prevent workers from developing common political interests.

In the Indian context, caste divisions can fragment labour and weaken the possibilities of collective resistance. Economic exploitation and social discrimination can reinforce one another, allowing established hierarchies to survive within modern capitalist relations.

These competing interpretations also influence historical methodology.

Subaltern historians emphasise the biases embedded in colonial archives and administrative classifications. They question the assumption that official records provide a complete or neutral account of historical experience.

Materialist historians, meanwhile, place particular emphasis on land ownership, taxation, labour relations and the extraction of economic surplus. They seek to understand how concrete economic arrangements shape social and political relationships.

The resulting disagreement reflects a broader tension between identity-based political mobilisation and universal redistributive demands. It also raises the question of whether economic class can provide an adequate basis for collective emancipation in a society where social hierarchy is organised through multiple, overlapping systems of power.

This is where Ambedkar’s understanding of caste becomes indispensable.

Ambedkar’s theory of caste and the limitations of class reductionism

Dr. B.R. Ambedkar and Marxist thinkers shared a fundamental concern with exploitation, inequality and human emancipation. Both sought to understand the structural conditions that perpetuate oppression and the possibilities of transforming society.

However, their approaches to the origins and organisation of inequality differed considerably.

Traditional Marxist analysis places economic relations at the centre of social structure. Class is determined by the relationship individuals have to the means of production, while the extraction of surplus value provides the foundation for capitalist exploitation.

Ambedkar’s analysis of Indian society cannot be confined to this economic framework. He understood caste as an autonomous system of social power, sustained by religious sanctions, inherited status, ritual hierarchy and restrictions on social relationships.

Caste is not simply an economic division. It organises society through birth-based identities and regulates marriage, social interaction, occupation and access to resources.

One of the most important features of Ambedkar’s analysis is the concept of graded inequality.

Unlike the broad horizontal division between capitalists and workers in conventional Marxist class analysis, caste creates a vertically organised hierarchy in which each group occupies a position above some and below others.

This arrangement has profound consequences for collective political action.

A system of graded inequality prevents the emergence of a unified subordinate population because social groups may experience different degrees of privilege and exclusion. Even those subjected to discrimination may retain forms of relative social superiority over other groups.

Consequently, the oppressed do not automatically develop solidarity with one another.

The system reproduces itself through endogamy and the enforcement of social boundaries. Economic relations alone cannot explain the persistence of these arrangements because caste hierarchy is sustained through social practices and religious authority that operate beyond the immediate sphere of production.

For Ambedkar, the destruction of caste therefore required a fundamental transformation of social relationships and the ideological foundations that legitimised hierarchy.

Class solidarity and the problem of caste

One of the central disagreements between Ambedkar’s approach and conventional Marxist interpretations concerns the assumption that economic transformation will eventually eliminate caste discrimination.

Abolishing private property or transforming ownership of the means of production cannot, by itself, guarantee the destruction of caste.

The working class is not a socially homogeneous group. Workers enter economic relationships carrying inherited caste identities, social prejudices and unequal positions within the wider society.

Caste discrimination can therefore continue inside workplaces and working-class organisations. Social exclusion may prevent people from eating together, working together on equal terms or developing a shared political identity.

The possibility of class solidarity is consequently limited when the social divisions within the working population remain unchallenged.

Ambedkar’s position places social reform at the centre of any meaningful programme of emancipation. Economic restructuring must be accompanied by the dismantling of caste hierarchy and the social practices through which it is reproduced.

This is a fundamental challenge to any political strategy that assumes class consciousness will emerge automatically from common economic interests.

For Ambedkar, the struggle against caste is not a secondary issue to be addressed after economic transformation. It is an essential condition for building an egalitarian society.

The state, constitutional democracy and social transformation

The differences between Ambedkar and traditional Marxism also extend to their understanding of the state.

Classical Marxist theory generally views the state as an instrument through which dominant economic classes maintain their power. The transformation of class relations is therefore closely connected to the revolutionary transformation of political institutions.

Ambedkar, in contrast, regarded constitutional democracy and the state as indispensable instruments for protecting individual rights and addressing structural inequalities.

For communities subjected to entrenched social discrimination, constitutional safeguards are essential. Legal protections, affirmative action and enforceable rights provide institutional means through which historically marginalised populations can challenge established power.

The state is not simply an institution to be dismantled. It can also become an instrument for securing social justice and preventing the concentration of power in the hands of dominant groups.

This difference reflects the distinct historical circumstances informing the two approaches. Ambedkar was concerned with a society in which social oppression was deeply embedded in religious authority, inherited status and everyday relationships. Political and constitutional safeguards were therefore necessary to protect those subjected to these structures.

Their differences also extend to the role of religion.

Marxist traditions have generally approached religion as an institution capable of legitimising existing social relations and discouraging resistance to exploitation. Ambedkar’s approach was more differentiated.

He rejected the religious foundations that sustained caste hierarchy, particularly the ideological justification of graded inequality within Hindu social organisation. At the same time, he recognised the potential of an ethical and egalitarian religious framework.

His embrace of Buddhism reflected his search for a moral and social philosophy based on equality, human dignity and ethical responsibility.

For Ambedkar, social transformation required more than changes in economic ownership or political institutions. It also demanded a transformation of moral values and collective consciousness.

Points of convergence: Beyond the opposition between Marx and Ambedkar

Despite their theoretical differences, Marxism and Ambedkar’s thought share an important emancipatory objective: the elimination of exploitation and the creation of a society based on human equality.

Ambedkar’s economic proposals also demonstrate that his approach cannot be reduced to a purely social or cultural critique of caste.

In States and Minorities (1947), he advocated an extensive programme of state socialism, including public ownership of land and key industries. His proposals recognised the importance of economic restructuring and the need to prevent the concentration of economic power.

This provides an important basis for examining the relationship between Marxist political economy and Ambedkarite social analysis.

Contemporary South Asian scholarship has explored different ways of bringing these perspectives together. Thinkers such as Sharad Patil, Anand Teltumbde and Gail Omvedt have contributed to discussions of the intersection between caste and class.

Such approaches recognise that caste and class cannot be understood as entirely separate systems. They interact within concrete economic and social relationships.

In agrarian society, for example, landownership and caste hierarchy may reinforce one another. Dominant caste groups may also occupy positions of economic power as landowners, while landless Dalits are disproportionately located among the most vulnerable sections of agricultural labour.

This relationship demonstrates how social status and economic position can combine to reproduce inequality.

At the same time, caste cannot simply be treated as another name for class. Its mechanisms of reproduction, including endogamy, ritual hierarchy and social exclusion, possess distinctive characteristics that require independent analysis.

A comprehensive understanding of Indian society must therefore recognise both the universal dynamics of capitalist exploitation and the historically specific structures through which social domination is organised.

Towards an integrated understanding of emancipation

The debate between Chibber and Subaltern Studies raises a fundamental question about the relationship between universal theories and particular historical experiences.

Chibber’s materialist critique highlights the danger of treating postcolonial societies as fundamentally exceptional and beyond the explanatory reach of political economy. The universal imperatives of capital remain important for understanding exploitation, labour discipline and economic inequality across societies.

The Subaltern Studies response, however, draws attention to the limitations of explanations that do not adequately account for local institutions, cultural identities and the independent political agency of subordinate groups.

Ambedkar’s analysis of caste makes the limitations of a purely economic interpretation particularly evident in the Indian context. The persistence of social hierarchy cannot be explained exclusively through ownership of property or relations of production. Caste is a deeply embedded structure of power that shapes economic opportunities, social relationships and political participation.

At the same time, caste cannot be adequately understood without examining its relationship with material resources, labour and economic power.

The challenge is therefore not to choose between class and caste as competing explanations of inequality. It is to understand their interaction without reducing one to the other.

An emancipatory political framework must address capitalist exploitation while confronting the social structures that fragment the oppressed and reproduce inherited privilege. Economic redistribution without social equality remains incomplete, just as social reform without addressing material exploitation cannot establish substantive economic justice.

The intellectual significance of bringing Marx, Subaltern Studies and Ambedkar into conversation lies precisely in this possibility. Their different approaches illuminate different dimensions of domination. Taken together, they provide a richer framework for examining the historical formation of inequality and the conditions necessary for its transformation.

The question of emancipation in India consequently demands an understanding of capitalism, caste and political power as interconnected but analytically distinct forces. Any project of social transformation that neglects one of these dimensions risks leaving the foundations of inequality intact.

Pon Chandran is associated with the People’s Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL), Coimbatore. He writes on political economy, social inequality, caste, Marxist thought and questions of social emancipation.